I and Murali Neelakantan have a piece out today in Scroll about the economics of the vaccination programme that is due to start in May ’21. Feedback most welcome – in particular, points we may have missed. Please, I’d love to hear your thoughts.
But it isn’t enough to talk about how current policy isn’t the best way of going about it. You also need to be thinking about what is the best (or at the very least, the least bad) way of going about it.
So, well, ok, let’s assume for the moment that the states will cough up the amount, one way or the other. But which way (or the other)?
Here are some ideas:
His back of the envelope calculations peg the tab for West Bengal at Rs. 8000 crores (do read the thread for his assumptions). As he says, that’s 2.6% of the state’s budgeted expenditure, and given the large positive
externalities spillovers, subsidization wouldn’t be a bad idea.1
You could do similar exercises for each state – but for the moment, let’s just assume that it’s around 2.5% of each state’s budgeted expenditure.2.
What might that do to state finances?
The covid-19 pandemic disrupted the finances of India’s states in the ongoing fiscal year. Expense needs grew and public debt swelled, while revenues shrank. While most states could return to pre-pandemic output levels next year, their fiscal indicators are likely to remain strained for much longer, projections by the 15th Finance Commission (15-FC) show.https://www.livemint.com/news/world/states-may-not-return-to-pre-covid-debt-levels-by-fy26-finance-comm-roadmap-11612765562078.html
States’ combined fiscal deficit is likely to have risen to 4.5% of their total gross state domestic product (GSDP) in 2020-21, from 2.5% in 2018-19, the panel said. The commission’s fiscal roadmap puts the figure at 3% by 2025-26. Debts by that year could still be 32.5% of the total GSDP, against 27.3% in FY20, the estimates show.
The kicker? That article is from the 8th of February, 2021. Things have, um, changed since then. The “while most states could return to pre-pandemic output levels next year” bit, in particular, now looks a bit iffy.
Next, Arvind Chari ran the numbers, and he comes up with a number of INR 50,000 crores for free universal vaccination:
Niranjan Rajadhakshya refers us to an article in which Maitreesh Ghatak and Tarun Jain recommend the issuance of public health bonds (not that this is from 2020):
Issuing bonds for 30 years’ duration matches the decades-long returns from investments in healthcare, and is about the time taken for a young child who benefits from health investments to become an active taxpaying adult. Very short-duration bonds mean that the repayment schedule will not match the boosts in tax revenue.https://m.economictimes.com/news/economy/policy/view-state-governments-can-be-better-armed-financially-to-fight-covid-19-by-issuing-public-health-bonds/amp_articleshow/76202188.cms?__twitter_impression=true
And they thankfully answer the obvious question in the very next paragraph:
Arguably, GoI could raise the same money at lower cost and then transfer to states. But, recently, GoI held up disbursing states’ share of GST collections at precisely the point that states needed those funds the most. Market borrowing limits by states have been raised subject to administrative conditions, and GoI could possibly impose conditions for health funds as well. Finally, borrowing directly allows each state government to prioritise its unique healthcare expenditure needs.https://m.economictimes.com/news/economy/policy/view-state-governments-can-be-better-armed-financially-to-fight-covid-19-by-issuing-public-health-bonds/amp_articleshow/76202188.cms?__twitter_impression=true
Note that the last sentence in the second excerpt doesn’t apply in today’s context.
What else could be done? I’ll try and update this post with articles as I read them – feel free to keep sharing them we go along.
- Truer, if anything, at the central level, but let’s not go there right now
- By the way, any GIPE student reading this: I have a fun project just waiting to be launched